Journal of Information Resources Management ›› 2025, Vol. 15 ›› Issue (6): 52-66.doi: 10.13365/j.jirm.2025.06.052

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Construction of an Evaluation Indicator System for High-Quality Datasets in the Data Element Market

Lin Zhenyang1,2,3  Wu Jiang2,4 Hu Xin5 Wang Jingxuan6,7 Yuan Yiming4 Du Le2,3   

  1. 1.Department of Computer Technology and Science, Tsinghua University, Beijing, 100084; 
    2.Wuhan Institute of Data Intelligence, Wuhan, 430072; 
    3.Institute of Big Data Rule of Law, Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology,Nanjing,210044; 
    4.School of Information Management, Wuhan University, Wuhan,430072; 
    5.School of International Political Economy, University of Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Beijing, 102401; 
    6.Big Data Development Department, State Information Center, Beijing,100045; 
    7.China Information Association, Beijing,100045
  • Online:2025-11-26 Published:2026-01-06
  • About author:Lin Zhenyang, Ph.D., senior engineer, research interests including digital economy and technological innovation; Wu Jiang, Ph.D., professor, research interests including data intelligence and technology empowerment; Hu Xin (corresponding author), master, research interests including digital economy and value realization of data elements, Email: hh11690@163.com; Wang Jingxuan, Ph.D., associate researcher, research interests including big data analysis and fundamental institutions of data elements; Yuan Yiming, Ph.D. candidate, research interests including information management and data elements; Du Le, master, senior engineer, research interests including data law and data elements market.
  • Supported by:
    This work is supported by the Special Project of the National Natural Science Foundation of China "Functional Orientation, Operational Mechanism, and Governance Mechanism of Data Trading Venues" (72442030), the National Social Science Foundation of China Project "Research on the Ownership Confirmation, Circulation, and Income Distribution of Data Elements from the Perspective of Marxist Political Economy" (23BKS031), and the 2024 Research Project of the Hubei Provincial Data Bureau "Construction of High-Quality Datasets in Hubei Province" (IM2409E085N1).

Abstract: This study aims to construct a scientific data quality evaluation indicator system as a fundamental basis for promoting the market-oriented allocation of data elements. It provides a quantitative benchmark for the transformation of data resources into assets and capital, thereby supporting the development of a value circulation mechanism in the data element market. Based on grounded theory, this study systematically analyzes policy documents, technical standards, and expert interview materials to build a multi-level evaluation indicator system comprising four main dimensions—compliance characteristics, scale-related attributes, content-specific properties, and value-oriented features—with 12 first-level indicators and 32 second-level indicators. This study further adopts the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and expert consultation methods to determine indicator weights and develop a practical, operable comprehensive evaluation model. Empirical validation through the selection of high-quality datasets in Hubei Province demonstrates the model’s effectiveness and practical applicability. The findings provide theoretical support and practical references for data asset valuation, improving data circulation efficiency, and optimizing value transformation pathways.

Key words: High-quality datasets, Grounded theory, Evaluation indicator system, Data elements, Data circulation and transaction

CLC Number: