信息资源管理学报 ›› 2024, Vol. 14 ›› Issue (3): 121-135.doi: 10.13365/j.jirm.2024.03.121

• 研究论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

基于用户评论的综合类政务服务APP使用满意度的影响机制质性研究

赵英1 邓慧丽2 李光耀1 陈诚3   

  1. 1.四川大学公共管理学院,成都,610065
    2.四川大学商学院,成都,610065
    3. 四川省发展和改革委员会,成都,610021
  • 出版日期:2024-05-26 发布日期:2024-06-14
  • 作者简介:赵英,博士,教授,博士生导师,研究方向为信息管理、信息用户行为研究;邓慧丽(通讯作者),硕士,讲师,研究方向为移动政务服务、数字化转型,Email:kelly220dhl@126.com;李光耀,硕士,研究方向为信息系统研究;陈诚,博士,研究方向为IT外包、数字化转型、供应商运营能力构建。

A Qualitative Study on the Impact Mechanisms of User Satisfaction of Comprehensive Government Service APPs Based on User Reviews

Zhao Ying1 Deng Huili2 Li Guangyao1 Chen Cheng3   

  1. 1.School of Public Administration, Sichuan University,Chengdu, 610065
    2.Business School, Sichuan University, Chengdu, 610065
    3.Sichuan Provincial Development and Reform Commission, Chengdu, 610021
  • Online:2024-05-26 Published:2024-06-14
  • About author:Zhao Ying, Ph.D., professor, doctoral supervisor, research interests: information management, information user behavior research; Deng Huili(corresponding author, Email: kelly220dhl@126.com), master, lecturer, research interests: mobile government services, digital transformation; Li Guangyao, master, research interests: information system research; Chen Cheng, Ph.D., research interests: IT outsourcing, digital transformation, operation capabilities building in IT vendors.

摘要: 探讨综合类政务服务APP使用满意度的影响因素及其作用机制,有助于更有针对性地完善功能设计和服务流程,进而提升数字政务水平。本研究将服务接触三元模型、服务接触满意度模型等作为参照理论,采用扎根理论对29个用户评论数据集进行分析,揭示出产品质量和使用情境两类共七个影响因素,并构建了三元主体模型以及过程模型。研究发现,产品质量越高、使用情境越贴近用户诉求,使用满意度越高;在使用前,使用情境中的APP推广的制度压力负向影响使用满意度;在使用中,产品质量正向影响使用满意度;在使用后,使用情境中的感知共情性正向影响使用满意度;同时,APP推广的制度压力对产品质量与使用满意度的正向关系起负向调节作用。本研究“动态”呈现了使用满意度影响因素的作用机制,丰富了管理信息系统领域过程理论和使用满意度的研究,拓展了服务接触满意度模型和制度理论等理论应用情境,可为后续使用满意度维度划分、制度压力调节作用等定量研究提供理论参考。

关键词: 综合类政务服务APP, 使用满意度, 用户评论, 过程研究, 扎根理论

Abstract: Comprehensive Government Service Apps are critical for delivering "one-stop" solutions for high-frequency government transactions and are essential for the development of efficient, collaborative digital governance. This study explores the determinants of user satisfaction and their mechanisms to inform targeted enhancements in app functionality and service processes, ultimately aiming to improve digital governance standards. Utilizing the Service Encounter Triad and the Service Encounter Satisfaction Model as theoretical frameworks, this study analyzed user reviews from 29 apps through Grounded Theory, identifying seven key factors within product quality and usage contexts. This study developed a triadic subject model and a process model to describe these dynamics and revealed that higher product quality and usage scenarios aligned with user needs lead to greater satisfaction. Institutional pressures in app promotion negatively influence satisfaction prior to use, whereas during usage, product quality positively impacts user satisfaction. After use, perceived empathy within the usage context enhances satisfaction. Additionally, institutional pressures negatively moderate the positive relationship between product quality and satisfaction. This study not only elucidates the complex mechanisms affecting user satisfaction but also enriches the management information systems literature by extending the applicability of established theories. The insights provided offer a theoretical basis for further quantitative studies on satisfaction dimensions and the regulatory effects of institutional pressures. Recommendations derived from this study could optimize digital governance services, promoting high-quality development and advancing digital transformation in China.

Key words: Comprehensive government service apps, User satisfaction, User reviews, Process study, Grounded theory

中图分类号: