信息资源管理学报 ›› 2024, Vol. 14 ›› Issue (6): 99-115.doi: 10.13365/j.jirm.2024.06.099

• 研究论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

基于相对引用方法的微信提及指标标准化研究

李龙飞1,2 余厚强3 杨思洛1,2   

  1. 1.武汉大学信息管理学院,武汉,430072; 
    2. 武汉大学中国科学评价中心,武汉,430072; 
    3.中山大学信息管理学院,广州,510006
  • 出版日期:2024-11-26 发布日期:2024-12-20
  • 作者简介:李龙飞,博士研究生,研究方向为科学计量与科学评价;余厚强(通讯作者),博士,副教授,研究方向为数据科学和替代计量,科学交流与科技评价,Email:yuhq8@mail.sysu.edu.cn;杨思洛,博士,教授,研究方向为文献计量与科学评价。
  • 基金资助:
    本文系国家自然科学基金面上项目“中国替代计量的数据识别机制与关键分析方法研究”(72274227)和广东省社会科学基金项目“标准化替代计量指标的构建方案与实证研究”(GD23YTS04)的研究成果之一。

A Study on the Standardization of WeChat Mention Metrics Based on Relative Citation Methods

Li Longfei1,2 Yu Houqiang3 Yang Siluo1,2   

  1. 1. School of Information Management, Wuhan University,Wuhan,430072; 
    2. Research Center for Chinese Science Evaluation(RCCSE), Wuhan University, Wuhan,430072; 
    3. School of Information Management, Sun Yat-Sen University,Guangzhou,510006
  • Online:2024-11-26 Published:2024-12-20
  • About author:Li Longfei, Ph.D. candidate, focuses on scientometrics and scientific evaluation; Yu Houqiang(corresponding author), Ph.D. and associate professor, focuses on data science and altmetrics, scientific communication and technology evaluation, Email: yuhq8@mail.sysu.edu.cn; Yang Siluo, Ph.D. and professor, focuses on bibliometrics and scientific evaluation.
  • Supported by:
    This is an outcome of the project "Study of Data Identification Mechanism and Key Analytical Methods for Chinese Altmetrics"(72274227) supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China, and the project "Construction Method and Empirical Study of Normalizing Altmetric Indicators"(GD23YTS04) supported by the Social Science Foundation of Guangdong Province,China.

摘要: 替代计量指标的标准化研究是指标应用于科技评价的重要前置研究。本研究面向中国自主知识体系建设,以中文学术论文的微信提及数据为研究对象,结合相对引用的标准化方法,融入传播影响力因素,构建微信提及指标的标准化指标,为中文替代计量数据源的开发、深化、应用提供相关参考和依据。研究主要结论为:①通过消除微信提及指标存在的时间差异、学科差异、高度稀疏性和偏态分布问题,微信提及的相关标准化指标可考虑应用于学术评价和社会影响力评价。②WI(WeChat Index)期刊集当中,被微信提及学术论文总数前三名的学科为哲学与人文科学、工程科技Ⅱ辑、农业科技。③本文基于微信提及频次构建的标准化指标WPP/FWSm和MNWS之间差异度较小,可用于单篇论文和期刊层面的微信关注度评价,但不适用于高校评价,易受到微信提及量分布特征的影响。④融入微信传播影响力指数的标准化指标WCPP/FWSm和MNWC能更好地平衡微信传播影响力和微信提及量的影响,且具有较好的稳健性好,是较有价值的标准化指标,可用于评价单篇论文、期刊、高校的微信关注度,在评价高校学术论文微信关注度和传播力时效果更好。

关键词: 替代计量学, 微信公众号, 替代计量指标, 微信提及, 指标标准化

Abstract: The standardization of altmetrics indicators is a crucial requirement for their application in scientific evaluation. This study targets the construction of a Chinese indigenous knowledge system, which focuses on WeChat mention data from Chinese academic papers. We used standardization methods based on relative citation methods and incorporated the WeChat Communication Index to establish standardized metrics for WeChat mentions. This research aims to provide relevant references and foundations for the development, deepening, and application of Chinese altmetrics data sources. Key findings include:(1) By eliminating time differences, disciplinary variations, high sparsity, and skewed distributions in WeChat mention metrics, the standardized indicators for WeChat mentions can be considered for application in academic evaluation and social impact assessment.(2) Within the WI(WeChat Index) journal set, philosophy and humanities, engineering II, and agricultural engineering are the top three disciplines with the highest number of WeChat mentions of academic papers.(3) WPP/FWSm and MNWS, metrics based on WeChat mention frequency, show minimal differences. These two indexes are suitable for evaluating WeChat attention at the level of individual papers and journals but are unsuitable for evaluating universities due to their influence by the distribution characteristics of WeChat mentions.(4) Standardized metrics, WCPP/FWSm and MNWC, incorporating WeChat influence indices, show a better balance between WeChat influence and mention volume. They demonstrate robustness and prove valuable for assessing WeChat attention at the individual paper, journal, and university levels. They are more effective in assessing the WeChat attention and the dissemination impact of academic papers in universities.

Key words: Altmetrics, WeChat official account, Altmetrics indicators, WeChat mention, Metric standardization

中图分类号: