信息资源管理学报 ›› 2023, Vol. 13 ›› Issue (4): 122-139.doi: 10.13365/j.jirm.2023.04.122

• 研究论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

走出搜索迷航:复杂探索式搜索过程中笔记记录的认知导航功能探究

孟高慧 刘畅   

  1. 北京大学信息管理系,北京,100871
  • 出版日期:2023-07-26 发布日期:2023-08-02
  • 作者简介:孟高慧,博士生,研究方向为用户信息行为;刘畅(通讯作者),博士,长聘副教授,博导,研究方向为用户信息行为,Email: imliuc@pku.edu.cn。
  • 基金资助:
    本文系国家社会科学基金一般项目“学习型搜索中用户交互行为与学习效果关系研究”(18BTQ090)的研究成果之一。

Avoiding Search Disorientation: A Study on the Cognitive Orientation Function of Note-Taking in the Complex and Exploratory Search

Meng Gaohui Liu Chang   

  1. Department of Information Management, Peking University, Beijing, 100871
  • Online:2023-07-26 Published:2023-08-02

摘要: 基于复杂探索式搜索任务这一理想研究情境,本文探究了笔记记录能否在搜索过程中发挥认知导航功能,以及不同笔记记录策略的功能区别,以发现笔记记录在支持用户搜索过程中的更大可能性。本文运用实验法收集数据。在数据分析阶段,首先使用项目分析、探索性因子分析、信效度检验方法开发复杂探索式搜索过程表现主观评价量表,然后使用描述性统计、配对样本差异检验来探究笔记记录对被试搜索过程的协助效果。结果发现,笔记记录能够在搜索过程中发挥认知导航功能,搜索过程的迷航表现、监控程度、有序程度是其认知导航功能的主要表现方面。此外,相较于提纲笔记,矩阵笔记能够更好地发挥认知导航功能。研究结论能够启发信息搜索系统在搜索中的笔记记录环节提升服务,以更好地支持具有探索性或复杂度的搜索情境。

关键词: 笔记记录, 探索式搜索, 复杂搜索, 认知导航功能, 搜索迷航, 量表开发

Abstract: Based on an ideal research context of complex and exploratory search task, this paper explores whether note-taking can play the cognitive orientation function and identifies the functional differences between different note-taking strategies to find more possibilities for note-taking to support the use’s search process. We collected data through user experimentation. In the data analysis stage, we first developed the Subjective Evaluation Scale for the Performance in the Complex and Exploratory Search Process through item analysis, factor analysis, and reliability and validity test, and then used descriptive statistics and paired sample difference test to explore the effect of note-taking on the participants' search process. The results show that note-taking can serve the cognitive orientation function during the search process. The cognitive navigation function is mainly reflected in user’s performance on coping with search disorientation during the search process, performance on monitoring during the search process, and performance on proceeding in order during the search process. In addition, compared with outline notes, matrix notes can contribute more to cognitive orientation. These conclusions can inspire the information retrieve system to improve its note-taking service to better support complex or exploratory search context.

Key words: Note-taking, Exploratory search, Complex search, Cognitive orientation function, Search disorientation, Scale development

中图分类号: